Pit bull must be put down

Judge bases her decision on severity of mailman’s wounds

By Lauren Hallow Published:

Bullasan, the pit bull who severely bit a Frankfort mailman, will be euthanized, a local judge has ruled.

Franklin District Judge Kathy Mangeot granted County Attorney Rick Sparks’ motion Tuesday that Bullasan be put down after he bit mailman Chis Lombardi June 28.

The pit bull’s owner, David Noel, of 214 Swigert Ave., objected to the motion and pleaded with Mangeot to reconsider.

“I’ve had him since he was 5 weeks old,” Noel said tearfully. “He’s part of the family.”

Mangeot said as a pet owner herself, the motion to put down Bullasan was “probably the hardest motion” that’s ever been before her. But she said she had to take into account Lombardi’s injuries, which she called “gruesome” and “severe.”

“As a dog lover and owner, I would sure hate to have a dog that was in my care that acted out in this manner,” Mangeot said.

“I know that he’s your pet; I know that you care for him … but I’m concerned that the public is at risk, and part of my duty is to make sure the public is protected.”

After the district court session, Noel declined The State Journal’s request for comment.

According to a statement from Lombardi to Frankfort Postmaster John Dampier the day of the incident, Bullasan attacked Lombardi as he was leaving Noel’s property after delivering his mail.

Pictures of Lombardi’s injuries show the pit bull bit a chunk out of his arm and left bite marks on his leg.

Dampier told The State Journal the day of the incident that it was one of the worst dog bites he’d seen in his 22-year career with the postal service.

Lombardi has yet to return to work, said Mike Wilson, supervisor at the local post office, adding he isn’t expected to return for a while.

He called the decision to euthanize Bullasan “good news.”

“Nothing against the animal, but it could’ve happened to somebody else. It could’ve been a kid,” Wilson said. “Luckily Chris was big enough to get the dog off him.”

Since the attack, Bullasan has been kept in quarantine at the Franklin County Humane Society. FCHS volunteer Teresa Masters, who accompanied Noel to Tuesday’s hearing, said Bullasan was “a perfect gentleman” while at the shelter.

The shelter veterinarian will be the one to euthanize Bullasan, but a date hasn’t been set, Masters said.

Sparks said he partly based his motion to euthanize Bullasan on the severity of Lombardi’s injuries.

“It’s a sad thing, but on the other hand, it was a gruesome attack,” Sparks said. “With that kind of behavior from a dog, I think that’s the only option you have is to put them down, be it a pit bull or a 10-pound Chihuahua.”

He said he also took into account Noel’s previous offense. According to court records, Noel pleaded guilty in 2005 to a misdemeanor charge of permitting a vicious dog to run at large after Bullasan was found running loose on Claxton Avenue, court records say.

In that case, Noel agreed that “further violations would result in forfeiture of the dog,” court records say.

Lombardi has filed a personal injury suit in Franklin Circuit Court against Noel, seeking unspecified damages. The suit also names Kelly Noel, but it’s unclear what her relation is to David Noel.

For Bullasan’s attack on Lombardi, Noel was charged with harboring a vicious animal – a city animal control ordinance. He was also charged with failure to produce documentation of rabies vaccination and failure to have rabies tags.

Noel will appear back in court on those charges in October.

Comments

Signed in as

By Posting to this site, you agree to our Terms of Service. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed. The State Journal doesn't necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post.

Want to leave your comments?

Sign in or Register to comment.

  • Can we put the owner down as well? If he has had run ins before with this animal, its not a case of not knowing what he was capable of. If you know your dog has that potential and you still let him loose... Sorry, my friend, you fail as a human.

  • Pets are like people. You think you know them and then they snap and do things out of the norm. This is a bad situation for both the dog and the owner. But even worse for the poor mailman that was only doing his job. Would not be surprised that this mailman never gets over the fear of dogs. I absolutely love animals but once they attack then it's time to re-evaluate the ownership of that animal. Our system is not broke Riggs it's the owner that was at fault. The judge was just doing her job to serve justice to the victim and protecting the public from further incidents.

  • I see these incidents on the news far too often. The little boy in Casey County that was attacked a few weeks ago was very, very lucky. I don't know the answer to the situation. I stopped taking my dog to the East Frankfort Park Bark because of so many pit pulls being there. I don't know when or which one of those could attack me or my dog. I am sorry for the owner because I know the dog was his pet.

  • I would not have a dog that was aggressive to people, period. Those men who have aggressive breeds and do not train them to be otherwise are compensating for their own perceived male inadequacies.

  • Are you sure about that Steve? I haven't raised my dogs to bite but I can't be 100% certain that one of them wouldn't. IMO dogs and people can both attack under certain conditions.

  • I disagree, anonymous. (No, not that anonymous. No, not that one either. Yes, that one.) None of my pack of three would bite a mailman. You can be sure they'd make noise, but they were raised better than to bite.

  • Its a good call, if that had been a kid,they would have been mauled to death.

  • The dog was in its own yard. The mail man was in its space. The dog was just protecting its family. It didn't know any better.

  • So sad.

  • So sad.

  • It's not the dogs fault, it's the owners.

  • It's a shame that the dog will have to suffer for the crimes and stupidity of the owner. In a better system, Noel would be flogged and the dog would go to another home for another chance at being rehabilitated. Sad that the dog will have to die. I just hope that the mailman recovers fully from his injuries.

  • I know the Noels love this dog. I love my dogs too but if one of my dogs ever attacks someone, I know what has to be done. There is too much risk in keeping a dog that has shown aggressive tendencies.