Home | Back

'Here Copper!'

Share_print Print Story    |    Comments    |   

“Copper … Here Copper … Copper!” Shawn Goodlett called wishfully as he led a search party into a thicket near Home Depot.

“I want her back,” the 11-year-old said earlier about the missing Shiba Inu who’s the same age as Shawn.

“I’ve known Copper since I was born.”

About two dozen searchers gathered early Saturday morning at the abandoned Home Depot site where a Frankfort policeman left Copper. A reward for her return is now more than $1,000.

They spread out on foot, in jeeps and cars to crisscross the area from Old Lawrenceberg Road to the East-West Connector, but there were no signs of Copper.

Lori Goodlett, Copper’s owner, said she had gone to places like the nearby Kroger and spoken to managers in case Cooper sought food in the vicinity.

“Copper has never been lost, so I am not sure what she would do, but I do think she would go toward people and food. She is definitely ignorant about traffic.”

Copper has been missing since July 3 after the manager of the Frankfort Humane Society, Regina McDaniel, demanded the dog be taken from the shelter because it was a coyote.

Goodlett said she was emotionally overwhelmed by the interest in Copper, whose plight has been widely distributed in print and broadcast media, originating with Thursday’s story in The State Journal.

“I have had strangers become friends this week.”

Unexpected among the searchers was Humane Society volunteer Jodie McDonald, who was at the shelter the day Copper was turned away.

“I wasn’t in the room when the officer was told to take the dog, but I did hear the exchange. A couple of people commented how sweet Cooper seemed, but were told the coyote could be sick and that was why it was being so calm.”

McDonald said many of the staff are caring, as are the volunteers.

“Some days it is just chaotic.”

Humane Society Board President John Forbes said earlier in the week he supported McDaniel’s decision that it was a coyote and not suited for the shelter.

“If she believed it was a coyote, she had every right to have the officer remove it,” Forbes said. “It is against the law for shelters to house coyotes.”

According to Maj. Fred Deaton, the police were told a coyote is considered a nuisance animal and may be shot or returned to the wild.

Copper’s story unfolded when a Frankfort police officer responded to a Gramma Drive resident’s call of a dog inside her privacy fence with her dogs. The officer retrieved the dog and put her in a crate and drove around until the shelter opened after noon on July 3.

Shortly after the officer left the dog, the desk sergeant at the Frankfort Police Department received a call from the shelter manager asking that the officer return.

Back at the shelter, the officer was told he’d have to remove the dog because it was a coyote and against the law to shelter one with domestic animals.

When the officer refused, his superior was called by the manager and told the officer he had to take the dog.

Under normal circumstances, Animal Control Officer Mark Pardi would have handled and responded to the initial dog complaint, but Pardi was on vacation.

While Franklin County Fiscal Court maintains both an animal control officer and an assistant, neither was called – a breakdown in the system, Second District Magistrate Phillip Kring says.

“These guys normally fill in for one another when they are going to be off. I don’t know why it didn’t happen in this situation.”

Since the Kentucky Department of Fish and Wildlife was closed that Saturday, police contacted independently-owned Wildlife Solutions about coyotes and were told of the option to dispose of or release them.

The responding officer drove to the grassy area behind Home Depot off U.S. 127 and released Copper from the crate.

That was the last time the copper-colored, 20-pound dog has been seen.

News of Copper’s release into the wild has been the subject of hundreds of media reports across the nation as outlets such as MSNBC and CNN picked up the story. From New York to Texas, reports about Copper have drawn criticism for the circumstances surrounding the shelter manager’s action.

Animal activist Trudi Johnson of Frankfort organized Saturday’s search. She announced to the group that $270 had been raised as a reward and that PETA was offering $1,000 for Copper’s safe return.

Johnson and the group discussed strategy and possible locations for the dog, including the possibility that Copper might be trying to find her way back to her Cloverdale home. Johnson held a stack of posters in her hand that were later posted around the area.

“We are all here because we can not believe this happened in our town. And from the calls and e-mails I have received, we never want to see it happen again,” Johnson said.

At one point Goodlett hoped Copper may have stayed in the vicinity and she placed her bed and a water bucket near the spot where Copper was released. It remained there Saturday.

“I have driven by here early in the mornings and late in the evenings hoping she might return,” Goodlett said.

Goodlett and her family also question how Copper was released from her home since the outside of the house is surrounded by a chain-link fence with clips that must be released to open the gates.

“She’d be more likely to be afraid to leave,” said Dave Turley, Goodlett’s father who accompanied her.

“I have no idea why anyone would want to let her out, but it seems strange to me she was in a fenced-in yard and she was found in a fenced-in yard,” Turley said.

Troy VanMeter and his wife, Holly, were among the searchers. Holly VanMeter passed a petition calling for more accountability from the Humane Society.

Ashley and Larry Estep said they came because they would be devastated if this had been one of their animals.
“We have a houseful of adopted strays,” Larry Estep said.

Joe and Michelle Vangilder were also among the searchers Saturday.  They had driven over from Jeffersonville, Ind., after seeing a report on a Louisville television station Friday night.

“We came because we could not believe a Humane Society would call this dog a coyote.”

The Vangilders own a non-profit pet pantry. Prior to moving to Indiana, they owned a pet rescue in Virginia for seven years.

“The standards for shelters are much higher in Virginia,” Michelle Vangilder said.

“Air flow returns in kennels are checked regularly as are the condition of cages. The record keeping is very strict. I don’t see the state veterinarian as active in Kentucky as I have in other states.”

Johnson will address the City Commission at its meeting 5 p.m. Monday.

“My hope is that they will be receptive to demanding more accountability from the shelter employees. At present they provide funding, but have no way assuring the community is being served.”

Johnson also has a meeting scheduled Thursday with Judge-Executive Ted Collins.

“It is still very hard for me to believe McDaniel thought Copper was a coyote. That policeman could never have handled him if it had been a coyote,” Johnson said. “This is just tragic.”

Searchers who spent several hours in the area turned up no trace of the lost dog, and Copper’s bed lay undisturbed.




Comments
By Posting to this site, you agree to our Terms of Service Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed. State-Journal.com doesn't necessarily condone the comments here, nor does it review every post.

Login above or Register to comment.
Jump to Page: 1 2 3
   Next 10 Comments of 27 Total Comments
27.
    Posted by capntrade August 2, 2010
Amen, Sellus! I used to wonder what all those bumper stickers were about, and now I know; kick it! DO NOT renew the contract with FCHS. I don't know if the LIFE House model is the answer; personally, I believe no-kill shelters are a bit unrealistic. If you keep every animals that comes in, obviously you run out of room and can't take more. Of course shelters should try by any means possible to get animals adopted out and/or keep them until they can, but some are simply too old, sick, and/or temperamentally indisposed to be adoptable. For those, I would simply hope for a comfortable, pain-free, and happy existence and a kind friend at the end. Even a suffering-free shelter would be a vast improvement over FCHS.

Please keep fighting for these poor creatures.

Will there ever be an investigation as to what really happened here; a lawsuit? Keep us posted.

26.
    Posted by sellus1 July 30, 2010
Based on the official reports that the FCHS provides the City, their average euthanasia rate is indeed right around 80%. The exact figure I calculated for the last year and a half (which is as far back as my data goes) was 78%.

Regarding calling a special meeting next week, only Commissioner May has expressed interest so far. Mayor Graham has flatly refused, and Commissioner Williams and Commissioner Carter have so far declined to respond to my request.

The County is already opening renegotiation of their contract with the FCHS next week, and the public clearly does not want us to keep dragging our feet on this. We should have and could have discussed this in appropriate depth at our most recent meeting on July 26th, but our City Solicitor misled us at that time into believing that we were bound by our contract with the FCHS. In his most recent correspondence with the Commission, however, Mr. Moore finally acknowledged that we do indeed have the ability to cancel our contract with the FCHS and negotiate a new one. We should not allow our City Solicitor's poor advice during our July voting meeting to delay our discussion of this issue for two full weeks. Our constituents expect and deserve more from us.

Sincerely,
Sellus Wilder
Frankfort City Commissioner
selluswilder@gmail.com

25.
    Posted by sellus1 July 28, 2010
The following is a letter to the editor that I sent to the State Journal earlier today:

Many people are understandably upset with the Franklin County Humane Society and its manager right now. The incident with Copper was both a tragedy for one of our residents and a national embarassment for Frankfort. This tragedy has also exposed some much deeper problems with our local animal shelter. I've received numerous disturbing reports of the FCHS refusing to participate in fundraising and foster activities that could help curb their exceptionally high euthanasia rates. It's clearly time for local governments to hold the FCHS more accountable for the public funds they receive and to demand more oversight over local animal control. (For the record, the City gives the FCHS $55,000 annually. The $56,500 figure that others have cited mistakenly includes funds for Project Graduation).
At our City Commission meeting last Monday night, I expressed a willingness to withhold funding from the FCHS unless they take concrete steps to address their high euthanasia rate and their reticence to work with other community groups and concerned citizens. The City Solicitor (aka: the City attorney) informed us that we presently can't do anything because we have a contract with the Humane Society that prevents us from withholding funds. I have since learned that this is not true at all. Our last contract with the FCHS expired in 2009, and we currently have no formal obligation to fund them.
I've requested that the City Commission call a special meeting this Monday (Aug 2) in order to reexamine our relationship with the Humane Society. This is a complex problem that needs to be addressed in a timely fashion. I expect to hear back from the rest of the Commission by the time this letter is published in Sunday's paper, but as of now I don't know whether or not they'll agree to meet to discuss this. If the rest of the Commission does indeed agree to meet next week, there should be an announcement in Sunday's paper.
We should negotiate a new contract with the Humane Society in order to formally obligate them to coordinate adoption, foster, spay/neuter and fundraising efforts with Lifehouse (a local no-kill animal rescue group) and other rescue organizations. This would go a long way towards reducing the unacceptable euthanasia rate in Franklin County. City and County governments should also each appoint a representative to the Humane Society's board to provide more oversight and accountability. Of course, this incident should also underscore the importance of maintaining proper identification tags on all pets.
I appreciated board member Paul Brooker's presence at our most recent City Commission meeting, and I don't doubt that the folks who donate their time and energy to the local Humane Society mean well and want to do their best for our community and its animals. The FCHS board may have to make some tough decisions in order to regain the public's trust, but I'm hopeful that this crisis will ultimately have a positive impact on animal control in Franklin County.

Sellus Wilder
Frankfort City Commissioner
selluswilder@gmail.com

24.
    Posted by capntrade July 28, 2010

23.
    Posted by capntrade July 28, 2010
To clarify (that was a jumbled mess), I didn't mean to say I think the dog was euthanized. I meant to say I'm afraid too much time has passed (it took weeks to even make this public; WHY?) for this dog to survive in the wild in this heat unless someone took her in. I think a lot of these sightings are wishful thinking, sorry to say. But we should by all means keep looking and especially at other shelters in case she was turned in by someone traveling down the highway. If the policeman was convinced it was a dog and not a coyote, he was wrong to turn it loose, even if he was "just following orders." The person giving those orders should be held accountable, as well as the total FAIL of a shelter manager.

22.
    Posted by kyana July 27, 2010
SadGirl, I live near Franklin Square which is close to the Home Depot property. There are coyotes in that area. When the weather gets cooler I can hear them howling while I stand in my backyard. I've even heard them when HD was still open.

I don't blame the police officer either. Even when called to come back to the shelter to retrieve the "coyote" he didn't want to, until his superiors ordered him to do so. I think he knew something was really wrong so he took photos. Very smart on his part. They are proof just how ignorant the shelter manager was for her decision.

As far as the dog being euthanized I highly doubt. How else were the photos taken? I can't give the shelter manager that much credit for thinking "Oh let's take a photo of the "coyote" then put it down". I think this incident is showing that the shelter manager isn't as smart as she thinks she is and people are catching on to her. Sorry the shelter board hasn't been that smart.

Lastly, for those that say they're giving to Life House or some other organization. Do one thing before you write a check. CHECK THEM OUT. Go to the facility. Talk to the volunteers not the director or the manager or a board member. The volunteers know what goes on in these places better than anyone. Ask where their supplies come from. Ask what they do with supplies they can't use. (You'd be amazed at how many organizations throw donated items away because the items are not deemed good enough). Ask to attend a board meeting. Ask to see an adoption application. Ask if they work with rescues. Ask, ask, ask.

If you don't like the answers you are given or have a gut feeling something is not right. Then put your checkbook back in your pocket or purse and RUN.

21.
    Posted by capntrade July 27, 2010
I hate to rain on anyone's parade, but I'm afraid Sadgirl's scenario (that the so-called humane society) immediately euthanized the animal vs. letting it loose; not sure where the cops fit in here. I don't distrust them, but they'd be in a lot of hot water if anyone wanted to actually SUE anyone here (hello, pet owner). I realize some believe in miracles, but some believe in Santa Claus, too; it's been way too hot out there for an elderly tame pet to survive in the wild. It's remotely possible someone took it in, but I seriously doubt it's out "playing" with children after three weeks lost and alone with no food, water, or shelter from the sun and the humidity.

Did I mention suing someone? Start with R. M.

The whole story is fishy.

20.
    Posted by stubbornasamule July 27, 2010
"I bet they already euthanized it. I don't trust the "Humane" Society here, never have, never will. I wouldn't take ANY animal there."

I don't believe that any euthanasia took place. I do have confidence in the police report and believe that the pictures were legitimate. There's no way a picture could be taken of a coyote being released from a crate unless there was one to open the crate and one to take the picture. That is not a task that could have been done by an individual.
The officer was doing what he was ordered to do but I do question why that particular area was chosen? Were the owners of the Home Depot property made aware that this was going to be done? There's been no response from them but I can't see they or any property owner would be very happy in having this done unless they had given prior permission.

19.
    Posted by I Spy July 27, 2010
OK, wait...let me get this straight...they thought it might be sick and that's why it was calm. Hmmm...so ANIMAL CONTROL gives the ok to release a SICK wild animal "back into the wild," which was an area that is actually just adjacent to Kroger, Penny's, WalMart...a sick, wild animal that could get sicker and run rampant through nearby parking lots full of people. Nice try. I bet they already euthanized it. I don't trust the "Humane" Society here, never have, never will. I wouldn't take ANY animal there.

18.
    Posted by debbie.dean1 July 27, 2010
I would like to assist in anything needed. Please contact me at 859-420-6379 - leave a message.

   Next 10 Comments | Home | Back